APEX-Agents · GPT-5.5 · dual
Law_World_419_WA_02
GPT-5.5 on APEX-Agents: Law_World_419_WA_02 (dual harness). Browse score, rubric, and public trace.
Grader rubric
Criteria verdict
States that CJ is a "responsible party" under 33 U.S.C. § 2701(32) based on charterer/operator status
FailStates that being a responsible party triggers strict liability for removal costs and damages under § 2702(a)
PassStates that § 2704(a)(1) establishes a liability limit of $2,500 per gross ton
FailStates that § 2704(a)(1) includes a statutory liability minimum of $21,521,000
FailStates that the gross ton liability limit is $74,617,500
FailStates that the gross ton liability is greater than $21,521,000
FailStates that CJ's liability cap is $74,617,500
FailStates that the third-party sole negligence under Section 2703(a)(3) is the strongest defense
FailStates that the third-party defense requires the defendant to prove that it had no contractual relationship with a third party affecting vessel operation
Pass
Prompt excerpt
Task context
Draft a pre-litigation legal memorandum that addresses CJ's status, financial exposure, and potential defenses under the Oil Protection Act of 1990. Create a new docx file, containing your memo.
Response trace
Agent response, tools, files, and edits
On mobile, open the full trace for the best view of the agent response, tool calls, file reads, edits, and grading context.
Open mobile trace